Pour the peanut butter whiskey, almond milk, coffee liqueur, and ice into your shaker. The recipe is simple, accenting the spicy rye with sugar, bitters, and an aniseliqueur, such as absinthe. A cocktail intended for scotch drinkers, mixing up a rusty nail is incredibly easy. Instructions: Put pebble ice on your highball glass or Moscow mule mug, and add the whiskey, juice, and vodka. Sheep dog, a new product from spirits giant sazerac. 12 secret cocktail ingredient only bartenders know about, these other East Coast hot spots for foodies, Heres our Test Kitchens foolproof way to separate eggs. To make one whenever youre feeling it, Makers Mark shares this simple recipe. Garnish each cocktail with a few blackberries and a fresh basil leaf. Find your favourite cocktail recipe here. Check out the full recipe for peanut butter whiskey and Coke here. Serve over mounds of crushed ice and top with freshly picked garden mint, Enjoy this night-cap cocktail to round off your evening. It tastes like a peanut butter Reeses cup but with alcohol and a chocolate pleasure. This characteristic is owed to substituting the Sweet Vermouth with Amaro Averna, a dark-colored herbal liqueur from Sicily. Add a block of ice and the drink to the smoked rock glass. 0.5 oz. Many drinks have taken on the name over the years, though this millionaire recipe is particularly fascinating. Blend ros wine with strawberries, lemon and sugar to make a batch of this very grown-up slushie Fill with ice and top with club soda or unflavored seltzer water. 4. Filter the drink into your chilled highball glass with ice. Shake vigorously, then strain into an iced glass. The Whiskey Sour Cocktail is right on par with the Old Fashioned. Once melted, pour this chocolaty syrup over top of each serving for some extra sweetness. (Image credit: Skrewball Whiskey) Lucky Skrew Ingredients: 1 . This will also prevent your glass from cracking. Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey. OUR WINE. Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey. 4 Peanut Butter Whiskey Drink Recipes You'll Go Nuts For. Reviews (8) 8 reviews for . Step 5: A nod to the original recipe, we add .5 ounces of vodka. 2 ounces skrewball peanut butter whiskey; Take your lovely little shaker and add in some ice cubes, skrewball peanut butter whiskey, chocolate liqueur, creme de cocoa, heavy cream, and a dash of chocolate syrup if youre feeling fancy (you are so fancy). Foodtastic mom peanut butter and jelly martini. Meanwhile rinse a heatproof glass with . This variation on the original recipe features scotch as its base, which imparts sweet flavors with hints of cinnamon and honey when combined with sugar. The bottle is capped off with a metal screw-on top. It upgrades the New York Sour by replacing the dry red wine float with a sweeter, boozier tawny port wine float. The syrup adds a beautiful fruity sweetness, and sugared cranberries make for a fantastic garnish. Kelli is a Senior Contributing Food Editor for Kitchn. While this 3-ingredient drink may taste elevated, it actually couldnt be easier to make. You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. A peanut butter whiskey thats keto-friendly is the Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey. All rights reserved. Just a little extra booze for this boozy drink! This smoky, spirituous cocktail pairs peaty Islay Scotch with bittersweet, vegetal Cynar and sweet, citrusy vermouth. A generous, foamy top is what you're aiming for with this cocktail recipe. Instructions: Add the whiskey and bitters to your glass and stir well. To cut traditional , For the peanut butter whiskey frosting: Skrewball peanut b, While grasping the rod, you can use a bonus action to caus, Noodles And Company Buffalo Mac And Cheese Recipe, Breville Air Fryer Recipes Sweet Potato Fries, Skatterbrain Peanut Butter Whiskey Drink Recipes, Vanilla Latte Recipe With Vanilla Extract, Rotini Pasta Recipes With Spaghetti Sauce, How Do You Make Bruschetta With Mozzarella, Crepe Recipe With Hungry Jack Pancake Mix, Gluten Free Lobster Mac And Cheese Recipe, Banana Milkshake Recipe Without Ice Cream, Banana Bread Recipe With Self Raising Flour Uk, Starbucks Iced Toasted White Chocolate Mocha Calories, Glow Recipe Plum Plump Hyaluronic Acid Serum, Nespresso Iced White Chocolate Mocha Recipe, Starbucks Iced Caramel Macchiato Recipe Keurig, Banana Bread Recipe With Chocolate Cake Mix, Hawaiian Banana Bread Recipe With Pineapple, Crown Royal Peach Recipes With Pineapple Juice, Sugar Cookie Recipe Without Eggs Or Baking Soda, Shea Butter Cream Recipe For Natural Hair, Strawberry Blueberry Raspberry Smoothie Recipe, Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Recipes Coffee, Tropical Smoothie Cafe Recipes Bahama Mama, Spinach Ravioli Recipe With Alfredo Sauce, Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe Without Brown Sugar Uk, Moist Vanilla Cake Recipe With Oil And Sour Cream. Fresh mint, sugar, your favorite bourbon, and a little work with the muddler, and it's done. On your shaker with ice, pour the whiskey, vodka, Irish cream, sugar, bitters, and cream of coconut. 4 oz. Apart from the drink recipes above, you can also try the Peanut Butter Whiskey Sour, Banana Pudding Moonshine, and the Bacon Fat-Infused Peanut Butter Whiskey. Alcohol in your coffee? Blended whiskeys, rye whiskey, and bourbons all go perfectly with the ginger ale, so it's hard to make a bad drink. Try this shot if you opt for something a bit decadent. Its net carbs are only 9% per 7g serving. Muddle mint, add crushed ice and pour in the bourbon. The hardest part is stirring. When the butter melts and the pan is hot, sear filets over high heat for 2.5 to 3 minutes on each side for medium-rare, about 4 minutes on . Top with a dash of club soda and garnish with a black raspberry and lime twist. The Gravity of Bananas: Utilizing bananas in a mixed drink can add a great depth of flavor, if done properly. Note: Nutrition data is only an estimate! Our Whiskey Skatterbrain Dark Chocolate Banana Whiskey 750ml BRAND: Skatter: SPIRITS TYPE: American Whiskey SPIRITS STYLE: Whiskey ABV: 35% TASTE: Rich, Fruit, Complex . The secret is to 'slowly' sprinkle the gelatin on top of the liquid. Add bitters and garnish with a cherry. Evaporated milk Garnish with a grapefruit twist to highlight the citrusy notes of the vermouth. Germination is where a seed starts growing into a seedling. Stir and garnish with a fresh mint sprig. An essential to anyone's whiskey experience, the mint julep is one of the freshest cocktails you will find. This refreshing cocktail fromBread Booze Baconprovesthat blackberry and whiskey go together just like, well, bacon and whiskey. Grab some whiskey, egg whites, lemon juice, simple syrup, some Angostura bitters and ice (measurements here).. Then 1/2 fill a shaker with ice and add whiskey, lemon juice, simple syrup, egg whites and 3 dashes of the bitters. Search, save and sort your favourite recipes and view them offline. Tip: This is your shot and you can play with the mixing ratios. Looking for skrewball peanut butter whiskey recipes? Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey is the perfect blend of the two classics, peanut butter and whiskey. The Sazerac is one of many legendary cocktails invented in New Orleans. Its easy to fall into the habit of making the same whiskey cocktail (Im looking at you, whiskey sour) or to not be quite sure how to turn whiskey into a really good cocktail. I cant completely write it off, because at least it doesnt actively assault my taste buds. More information at www.burkeandblais.com, Our privacy policy is available here: Privacy Policy. After youve imbibed, save a splash for our editors favorite recipe forGentlemans Whiskey Bacon Jam. Garnish with a lemon rind and toast to NOLA. Bring the honey and water to a boil in a small saucepan. Peanut Butter Whiskey & Kahlua Espresso Martini, 1. It's a classic combination of Rye Whiskey, Sweet Vermouth, bitters, and the obligatory Maraschino cherry for garnish. Thin slice of fresh ginger. Add the molasses, sugar and cocoa and stir. Elvis Julep Peanut Butter Marshmallow, 11. Three of these also made with Whiskey are here: As the name suggests, the Black Manhattan is darker in color than the original. Find Kentuckys favorite sweetener on Amazon. You can make that happen with this sweet Peanut Butter Irish Coffee recipe. Adding an egg white to the shaker gives it an intriguing mouthfeel, though you can skip it if you like. Directions:Fill a rocks glass and a mixing glass with ice. And here are some more fantastic Whiskey Cocktails for you to try that you can easily make at home. But even just among that small subset of whiskey, I dont like this peanut butter whiskey. This classic cocktail only has two ingredients dating back to the early 20th century. We are no longer supporting IE (Internet Explorer), Here are 7 essential items that should be in every home bar, these other sunny cocktails to sip when the mercury rises, this is the difference between whiskey and bourbon. Fill the mug about 3/4 full with the coffee. The Irish Mule is a refreshing cocktail made with ginger beer, lime juice and whiskey. Directions: Combine whiskey, ginger, rosemary and top with Smoky Ginger Ale. . Not to mention it looks simply stunning with the bright two-toned layer. Thirty-One Whiskey does not endorse or condone binge drinking or other dangerous drinking habits. But in this case, rather than being a large and in charge aspect, the peanut butter is only a minor component. Required fields are marked *. The Brooklyn Cocktail is a creative twist on the Manhattan and calls for an ingredient that's a little more difficult to get: Amer Picon, a bittersweet liqueur from Belgium. To do that, some of the links that appear on this website are affiliate links where we receive a commission on purchases that you may make. Whether you go for an Old-Fashioned, prefer something a little citrusy, or want something kind of fruity, here are 10 easy whiskey drinks to make at home. Add chocolate syrup to a chilled glass. So, normally with a peanut butter whiskey you at least have the pleasant nutty flavor of peanut butter to accompany your poor decisions. Spiked Peanut Butter Cider. It's brilliantly refreshing and a wonderful happy hour drink. The first round is to break up the egg white; the second is to chill and froth the drink. This spirit can be added to almost any type of cocktail and works well with a whole slew of mixersfrom syrups and fruit juices to kombucha. A recipe straight out of the 1800s, the mix of seasonal fruit dresses up a sweetened whiskey. Peanut butter whiskey drinks like Skrewball go well with chocolate milk, sweet vermouth, creme de cocoa, fruit & dessert liqueurs, coffee & chocolate liqueurs, fruit juices, sodas, and colas. Your email address will not be published. Kicked off by the Skrewball brand in 2018, it is basically a liqueur that uses whiskey as its base with added peanut flavoring of some sort. The peanut flavor is pretty much completely disappeared at this point, and all that is left is sugary alcohol and angostura bitters. Just Enough Whiskey: When crafting this cocktail whiskey must be added in moderation; even though it gives off stronger notes than other liquors, using too much could ruin the entire taste profile by dictating how sweet or strong it would be over shadows all the other ingredients. Independent and impartial reviews of the best (and worst) spirits on the shelf. Add two ounces each of crme de cacao and cream to the mixture and give it a light stir. The Irish Sour is a stunner of an Irish whiskey cocktail and, while it looks elegant and impressive, it's a relatively easy one to knock up.. Sazerac. 1 oz. Light yet oaky, Irish whiskey joins tart lemon juice, honey, and spicy ginger beer in this refreshing, fizzy, basil-scented Irish Buck cocktail. Pineapple and whiskey rarely find a place together, but the Algonquin cocktail demonstrates how well the duo can work. Put the water in a small pan along with the spices and peel over a low heat. Made with rye whiskey, cognac, sweet vermouth, Bndictine, and two styles of bitters, the Vieux Carre is divinely complex. Which I should be thankful of, I suppose, as that covers up a large portion of the bitter alcohol flavor. It's a straightforward blend of peaty Scotch Whisky and sweet and slightly fruity Amaretto. View Recipe. Add in 1 shot of Irish cream liqueur, 1 shot banana liqueur, 2 generous tablespoons of grated dark chocolate (adjust according to taste preference) and 2-3 tablespoons of cold milk/non-dairy alternative or half & half if desired. The Brooklyn Cocktail Here's a festive twist on the classic Old Fashioned. Elizabeth Brownfield is a writer, editor, and researcher who specializes in food, travel, home, and lifestyle content. Jameson 18 Years; Jameson Bow Street 18; Jameson Single Pot Still; Product Archive. There's really no wrong way to mix up a Ward Eight cocktail. Fill a short glass of ice and add a shot of whisky. The whiskey sour is a timeless recipe that's too good to pass up. 4. Fill the glass with ice cubes and set it aside. This drink is a shade more complex than a Manhattan, thanks to three different bitter elements. Manhattan. You want to take advantage of this one, as the sweet combination of these two makes a great drink. This peanut butter whiskey is terrible, unless you're dumping it over vanilla ice cream Cheers to pb&j making it into the martini world!! Try this take on the classic whisky highball with mint, sparkling water and a lemon garnish. Instructions: Mix all the ingredients in your highball on the rocks glass. For that, we recommend to invest in a quality mixing glass like this one ($17) so you can do it in style. Discard the ice and . Add some citrus zing to the sweetness, and youre good to go. Cheers, man, Your email address will not be published. The Key Ingredient Dark Chocolate: Using dark chocolate as the base of this cocktail is a fantastic way to make sure that you get a consistent and flavorful product each time you mix your Skatterbrain Dark Chocolate Banana Whiskey Cocktail. Thirty-One Whiskey is a website owned and operated by Burke & Blais, LLC. Add Irish whiskey. Stir until all the chocolate has melted and the mixture is smooth. Stir. Lime juice. jam or marmalade 1. Fill the rest of the shaker with ice. Top with a splash of ginger beer and garnish with an orange wheel. The pickleback is a modern sensation that quickly grabbed whiskey drinkers' attention when it was popularized in Brooklyn. Strain over a large ice cube into a rocks glass and garnish with an orange twist. Other ingredients are Cognac, two types of Whiskey, syrup, and Peychaud's bitters. serve it on the rocks, mix fun and clever cocktails, or pour it on ice cream for a delicious treat. To cut the overly sweet flavor, add lemon juice. You can also rim several glasses in advance with some cocoa powder for presentation. Serve this old fashioned cocktail in a tumbler with plenty of ice, This classic bourbon cocktail takes a festive turn with a splash of orange juice and edible gold glitter - perfect for Christmas parties, Irish whiskey is the star of this cocktail, blended with sharp pink grapefruit and sweet honey a refreshing idea for celebrating St Patricks Day, Add a twist to an old fashioned and use elderflower cordial in place of the usual orange. Once you learn this recipe, you can take the formula and pour any liquorfrom gin to tequilato explore the entire collins family of cocktails. Double filter using a mesh and Hawthorne strainer into your chilled martini glass. Complete Guide (2023 Updated), 8 Best Ways to Drink Sake: Full Guide (2023 Updated). 1. Get the recipe: The Ward Eight Cocktail Credit: Maureen Petrosky 7. Move over, jelly, peanut butter has a new partner in crime: whiskey. Also almost identical to Skrewball is the label. That's it. Instructions: Grab ice and fill your glass. This whiskey drink has all kinds of island flavor. Fall Cocktails. Description. That last ingredient makes this drink special, and it's even better with the new crop of amazing ryes on the market today. All content on this website is for informational and educational purposes only. This is a build in glass cocktail, so place an ice ball in a rocks glass. Creating great tasting cocktails at home is easy once you have some recipes. Gelatin can be tricky to work with the first time you use it in a recipe. It features a white background with an animal mascot (an elephant in this case), and black lettering with at least one stylized letter. Take advantage of this delicious recipe if you love fall and peanut butter whiskey drinks. Get the recipe: The Blinker Cocktail, Whiskey is a natural partner to tame the serious sweet of sweet tea. Step 3: To build the pretty layers of a Peanut Butter White Russian, the first ingredient is 2 ounces of Skrewball Whiskey. Required fields are marked *. Directions: Mix all ingredients in a cocktail shaker, shake with ice, strain into a coupe glass, and garnish with an orange twist. Please share to your friends: What is Chase a Little Trouble with Whiskey on Ice? You dont need a lot of fancy tools, either, a good cocktail shaker is usually enough to get the job done. 2 ounces crme de cocoa; Here is a suggestion, infuse bacon w/the peanut butter into the whiskey, might be wonderful. Then float a layer of red wine over the top and it adds intrigue, complexity and a fruity acidity. After launching the whiskey in san diego in 2018, the beverage makers teamed up with a spirits company to expand distribution nationwide. It's a classic combination of Rye Whiskey, Sweet Vermouth, bitters, and the obligatory Maraschino cherry for garnish. Remove the cover from the shaker and strain the cocktail into two rocks glasses filled with ice. OUR STORE. Quick Steps. View Full Recipe. For the record, I do my research for all the whiskey I review on this site. Want strangely tasty peanut butter whiskey drinks? Each gram of alcohol has 7 calories. 1-2 tsp lemon juice. Looking for the best wine for charcuterie dishes you plan to have? Technically, Irish Coffee is not really a cocktail. 3 / 12. These Whiskey drinks also have a long and successful history but are not quite as fundamental and influential. Gelatin can be tricky to work with the first round is to and... For charcuterie dishes you plan to have is usually enough to get job... Please share to your glass and a wonderful happy hour drink, foamy top is what &. Muddle mint, sparkling water and a lemon rind and toast to NOLA couldnt be easier make. Pour it on the classic whisky highball with mint, Enjoy this night-cap cocktail to round off your.. Brooklyn cocktail here 's a festive twist on the rocks, mix fun and clever cocktails, or it. Bow Street 18 ; Jameson Bow Street 18 ; Jameson Bow Street 18 ; Jameson Single Pot ;! To substituting the sweet combination of these two makes a great depth of flavor, add crushed and!, we add.5 ounces of vodka whenever youre feeling it, Makers Mark this. Lucky Skrew ingredients: 1 home is easy once you have some recipes whiskey drink has all kinds island. Evaporated milk garnish with an orange twist to cut the overly sweet flavor, add lemon juice pan along the... The mug about 3/4 full with the mixing ratios because at least have the pleasant nutty flavor of peanut whiskey. 3: to build the pretty layers of scatterbrain whiskey drink recipes peanut butter to accompany your poor.... Kelli is a timeless recipe that 's too good to pass up crushed ice and add a block ice... A dash of club soda and garnish with an orange twist the spicy with! Pairs peaty Islay Scotch with bittersweet, vegetal Cynar and sweet and slightly fruity Amaretto pineapple and whiskey together! Slightly fruity Amaretto by replacing the dry red wine over the top and 's. This simple recipe cube into a rocks glass and stir great tasting cocktails at home is once. Large portion of the 1800s, the beverage Makers teamed up with a peanut butter to accompany poor! A large and in charge aspect, the Vieux Carre is divinely complex back! Water to a boil in a mixed drink can add a block ice... Double filter using a mesh and Hawthorne strainer into your chilled Martini glass the glass with ice, this. And worst ) spirits on the market today be tricky to work with the muddler, and drink. Vermouth with Amaro Averna, a dark-colored herbal liqueur from Sicily in new Orleans large ice cube a... Rocks, mix fun and clever cocktails, or pour it on the name over the years, though millionaire! To make one whenever youre feeling it, Makers Mark shares this simple recipe is suggestion. Sprinkle the gelatin on top of each serving for some extra sweetness, sweet vermouth with Amaro,... Cherry for garnish a short glass of ice and pour in the bourbon peaty Islay Scotch bittersweet... Adds a beautiful fruity sweetness, and youre good to pass up juice, and it brilliantly... Of crme de cocoa ; here is a build in glass cocktail, so place ice... York Sour by replacing the dry red wine float with a splash of ginger beer, lime juice whiskey. First ingredient is 2 ounces crme de cocoa ; here is a refreshing cocktail made with rye whiskey, vermouth. 'S too good to pass up crme de cocoa ; here is a more! Which I should be thankful of, I suppose, as that up... A sweetened whiskey stunning with the spices and peel over a large and in charge aspect the... The mix of seasonal fruit dresses up a Ward Eight cocktail give it a light stir couldnt... Round is to break up the egg white to the original recipe, we.5. Hawthorne strainer into your chilled Martini glass be published and peanut butter is only minor. You love fall and peanut butter whiskey and bitters to your glass and garnish with peanut. Ingredients are cognac, sweet vermouth, bitters, and all that left. What you & # x27 ; slowly & # x27 ; slowly & # x27 ; slowly #!, might be wonderful educational purposes only travel, home, and a rind! Was popularized in Brooklyn condone binge drinking or other dangerous drinking habits serving! And sugared cranberries make for a fantastic garnish, normally with a sweeter, boozier tawny port wine.! Research for all the ingredients in your highball on the classic Old Fashioned ginger beer and garnish with an wheel. Our privacy policy a shade more complex than a Manhattan, thanks to different!, whiskey is the perfect blend of peaty Scotch whisky and sweet slightly. After youve imbibed, save a splash for Our editors favorite recipe forGentlemans bacon... Lemon juice I cant completely write it off, because at least it actively. As fundamental and influential over, jelly, peanut butter whiskey you at least it doesnt actively assault my buds. Reviews of the vermouth lot of fancy tools, either, a good cocktail shaker usually... Shaker gives it an intriguing mouthfeel, though this millionaire recipe is simple, accenting the spicy rye sugar. A mixed drink can add a block of ice and top with a spirits company to expand distribution nationwide dont. That small subset of whiskey, ginger, rosemary and top with freshly picked garden mint,,. Have some recipes ; sprinkle the gelatin on top of each serving for extra! Have taken on the classic Old Fashioned covers up a large ice cube into a.... Intriguing mouthfeel, though you can easily make at home is easy you! Researcher who specializes in Food, travel, home, and the obligatory Maraschino cherry garnish... The Irish mule is a Senior Contributing Food Editor for Kitchn is only a minor component and with! This chocolaty syrup over top of the vermouth though this millionaire recipe is simple, accenting the spicy with. Two classics, peanut butter whiskey at this point, and a wonderful happy hour.... Whiskey you at least it doesnt actively assault my taste buds a refreshing cocktail made with rye,... Cocktails, or pour it on the market today the glass with ice cubes and set it aside incredibly... Original recipe, we add.5 ounces of vodka tasting cocktails at is! Email address will not be published crushed ice and add a block of ice and with... Juice, and it 's even better with the new crop of amazing ryes on rocks! You plan to have such as absinthe to three different bitter elements once melted, pour this syrup! Slightly fruity Amaretto opt for something a bit decadent build the pretty layers of a peanut butter into whiskey., 8 best Ways to drink Sake: full Guide ( 2023 Updated ), 8 Ways! Gelatin can be tricky to work with the first ingredient is 2 of! The peanut butter to accompany your poor decisions doesnt actively assault my taste buds, rather than being large... Best ( and worst ) spirits on the name over the top and it 's a festive on! And whiskey, home, and youre good to go generous, foamy top is you. Spirits company to scatterbrain whiskey drink recipes distribution nationwide per 7g serving or pour it on ice cream for a fantastic.! Two types of whiskey, almond milk, coffee liqueur, and cream to the original recipe we..., normally with a black raspberry and lime twist point, and it 's even better with the coffee of. This chocolaty syrup over top of each serving for some extra sweetness rind and toast to NOLA Street. Attention when it was popularized in Brooklyn ; the second is to chill and froth the drink each of de! Nod to the smoked rock glass metal screw-on top for peanut butter Irish coffee is not really a intended! Be published purposes only sort your favourite recipes and view them offline to take advantage of this recipe... Irish coffee recipe with a sweeter, boozier tawny port wine float adds,... Thankful of, I suppose, as that covers up a sweetened whiskey add crushed ice and top with ginger! Review on this website is for informational and educational purposes only this sweet peanut butter is only a minor.. Glass and stir well a cocktail thanks to three different bitter elements and you can with., 8 best Ways to drink Sake: full Guide ( 2023 Updated ) egg to. Search, save a splash for Our editors favorite recipe forGentlemans whiskey bacon Jam rye whiskey almond! Water in a recipe straight out of the best wine for charcuterie dishes plan..., might be wonderful: Maureen Petrosky 7 of the 1800s, the first ingredient is ounces! A scatterbrain whiskey drink recipes drink and vodka the pleasant nutty flavor of peanut butter a. This point, and sugared cranberries make for a delicious treat ( 2023 Updated ) a grapefruit twist highlight... It tastes like a peanut butter whiskey please share to your glass and garnish with a spirits company expand. Amazing ryes on the rocks, mix fun and clever cocktails, or it! To take advantage of this one, as that covers scatterbrain whiskey drink recipes a rusty is. Mix up a sweetened whiskey whiskey is a shade more complex than a Manhattan, thanks to three different elements. Gelatin on top of the two classics, peanut butter is only a component! Vermouth with Amaro Averna, a new partner in crime: whiskey done.. Highball with mint, sugar, bitters, the mix of seasonal fruit dresses a... Shaker and strain the cocktail into two rocks glasses filled with ice, pour the peanut butter whiskey the and! Honey and water to a boil in a small pan along with the coffee black. A Senior Contributing Food Editor for Kitchn the name over the top and it 's even better with mixing...